Home
Image45

Power with not over children

Discipline is an environmental issue.  It’s how you establish this environment where kids can do a lot.  You cut down a lot on those kinds of things.  If you understand kids can’t share, kids can’t take turns, kids can’t collect information, there’s things that kids can’t do, it’s a better environment for this.  For me what really matters is the golden rule, I’m going to treat you like I want to be treated and I don’t want to be put in time out.  I don’t want to be jerked around.  I don’t want to be talked to in an inappropriate way.  We can get through this.  We’re going to be okay.  That’s what you want to do.  You don’t want the pain and the anguish and the embarrassment to linger very long. 

Things to think about

In what ways can you establish an environment that respects children are egocentric and cuts down on discipline problems as a result?
Do you have a set of rules for children?
How do you hold boundaries with children that does not shame or punish them?
When you have a problem with a child, do you look for the root causes first?
Are children made to come to gathering times?  Why or why not?

Highlights from Playful Wisdom
by Michael Mendizza featuring Bev Bos and Joseph Chilton Pearce

Personally I don’t like strollers. I prefer carrying small children to pushing or lying them in a trendy three-wheel stroller. I can feel their soft face next to mine as we make funny sounds together, not loud, just between the two of us. As we walk I can rub their feet, knowing that tiny nerve endings move up from her paws to every part of her body. Forget all the brain stuff. I do it because it feels good. Lying in the stroller means the child is not being touched. Convenient for me, indeed, but sensory deprivation for the child – and sensory deprivation for me too, but most adulterated-adults are too busy with themselves to notice. In a sensory deprived culture, we often don’t consider sensory deprivation – sensory deprivation.

“If we have pleasurable sensory stimulation, that’s the brain engrams, the templates that will be stored, and they will be images of pleasure. If they are painful there are going to be images of pain, and pain evokes violent responses. But there is something else that invokes violent responses, and that is the absence of pleasure, and that is really different than the sensory event of pain, and most people don’t appreciate that distinction. In fact, more damage occurs with the sensory deprivation of pleasure than the actual experiencing of physical, painful trauma, which can be handled quite well in individuals who have been brought up with a great deal of physical-affectional bonding and pleasure, which carries with it emotional trust and security. So we really have to look at the trauma of sensory deprivation of physical pleasure, and that translates into the separation experiences, the isolation experiences of the infant and the mother. That’s the beginning, the origins of violence.” James Prescott, PhD.

 

Power over children means that you’ve got a set of rules and if they get broken then you do something to punish the child instead of assisting the child through this.  First of all one of the things we need to do some of the times, we need to help kids hold the line.  They don’t know boundaries yet and I can be there to help you but I also don’t want to shut down the kid’s brain.  You really want to, first of all, I think discipline is an environmental issue.  It’s how you establish this environment where kids can do a lot.  You cut down a lot on those kinds of things.  If you understand kids can’t share, kids can’t take turns, kids can’t collect information, there’s things that kids can’t do, it’s a better environment for this.  For me what really matters is the golden rule, I’m going to treat you like I want to be treated and I don’t want to be put in time out.  I don’t want to be jerked around.  I don’t want to be talked to in an inappropriate way.  We can get through this.  We’re going to be okay.  That’s what you want to do.  You don’t want the pain and the anguish and the embarrassment to linger very long.  So when you think of that and you think about power, how can I help this kid through this?  The other thing I think that we don’t do very well, that we need to really talk about a lot, and I don’t hear many people talking about this what you have to look for always with kids is root causes, what’s going on?  Is it a stage?  Are they tired?  Are they weary?  Do they need to be held?  Are they hungry?  All sorts of things.  You know what I think about, I think about myself going to school.  I walked to school with my brothers and sisters and we horsed around all the way there.  These kids, some of our kids are driven as far as thirty miles in these seat belts and these car seats and they can’t move their heads and their parents might be on the cell phone.  What kind of a way is that to start a day?  Then they’re really, sometimes we say kids are angry.  Anger is always secondary.  Something else has happened first.  So if you can figure out what’s going on here and that’s what I always think about.  I think we jump in there with power over the kid by gum, then they go into the reptilian brain and there can be absolutely no growth there for me.  So I want power with the kids.  One of the things I say, “I can’t let you do that.”  That doesn’t mean that what you’re doing is so bad, it just means that in this place this is not okay.  And then we try to figure out what else we can do.  But I have to tell you that we have literally hundreds of people visit our school every year.  Sometimes as many as four or five a day.  The number one thing they remark upon is that oh well these kids are different because they don’t fight like ours do.  They’re the same as every other group of kids there is.  What it is it’s an environmental issue.  You get personal power when you make decisions based on your values and your desires and you give up power when you let other people make decisions for you.  So I want kids to make as many decisions for themselves as they can and all I have to do is establish an environment where that can happen.  One of the most noticeable things in this school is you would never have to come to a gathering, a circle, a group time, whatever it is you call it, no child would ever be coerced or made to come because then that child who is coerced into coming creates havoc and then we go into what we think is discipline and embarrass the child or hurt the child and we’ve created the whole situation.  So we take care that we’ve established an environment where it’s going to be really kind to children. It’s not going to kill the spirit.  It’s not going to kill the desire to know everything on this planet.  Why, and I think when you have egocentric adults thinking to themselves oh I’ve got this really good book, I’ve got this really good story, oh this is going to be really good, and I’m going to make the kids be interested.  Nothing could be further from the truth.